Oct 08, 2026 by Offer

Macquarie Interview Questions 2027: Valuation Methods Compared (How to Answer)

Answer directly: there is no universally "highest" method — it depends on assumptions — but in practice, the DCF often produces the highest valuation because its terminal value embeds optimistic long-term growth assumptions, while trading comps reflect current market pricing and precedent transactions include control premiums. Then explain the logic behind each.

What Macquarie Interview Questions Like This Assess

The interviewer wants to see whether you understand the three methodologies deeply enough to compare them — their inputs, biases, and what each one actually measures. A candidate who can explain why valuations differ across methods demonstrates real valuation judgment, not just memorised steps.

How to Answer Macquarie Interview Questions: Compare the Three Methods

DCF (intrinsic): Values the company on its own projected cash flows. Tends to run highest in practice because analysts' long-term growth assumptions are often optimistic, and the terminal value — frequently the largest component — compounds those assumptions. Its weakness: highly sensitive to inputs.
Trading comparables (market): Values the company at multiples (EV/EBITDA, P/E) paid for similar public companies. Reflects current market sentiment — no control premium, since these are minority stakes. Usually the lowest of the three in a healthy market.
Precedent transactions (market): Uses multiples from past M&A deals. Typically higher than trading comps because acquirers pay a control premium (often cited in the 20-40% range historically, though this varies by market and era — do not state it as a fixed rule).

Sample line: "In practice the DCF often comes out highest because its terminal value bakes in optimistic perpetual growth, while trading comps reflect where the market prices similar assets today without a control premium. Precedent transactions sit in between or above comps because they include what acquirers actually paid for control."

Close with the triangulation point: bankers use all three and present a valuation range (the "football field"), not a single number.

Common Mistakes

Stating "DCF is always highest" as a rule: It is a tendency driven by assumptions, not a law. Qualify it.
Forgetting the control premium: The premium is the key reason precedent transactions exceed trading comps — omitting it leaves the comparison unexplained.
Not mentioning the football field: Strong candidates close by noting that practitioners triangulate across methods into a range.

This comparison question is a favourite follow-up in technical Macquarie interview questions — it is asked precisely because there is no single textbook answer. This question is commonly reported by candidates.

Keep Reading

FAQ

What is a football field chart? A valuation summary showing the ranges from each methodology side by side — the standard output of a valuation exercise in banking.

When would trading comps give the highest valuation? In a market bubble, when public multiples are stretched beyond what fundamentals or past deals would support.

What is a control premium? The extra amount acquirers pay over the market price to gain control of a company — reflecting synergies and the value of control itself.

Which method do bankers rely on most? It depends on the situation: DCF for intrinsic debates, comps for market reality checks, precedents for M&A pricing. Professionals triangulate rather than relying on one.

Preparing for Macquarie's interview? Our 2027 Macquarie Online Psychometric Assessment Tutorials has practice questions and answers — $79 one-time, instant download.